Moon Sighting

All of the Moon Sighting News and Resources You Need

Home Introduction Calendars Slideshow Eid al-Adha Moonsighting FAQ Hilal Pictures Articles Why Confusion Updates Volunteers Links Archive

Why Confusion

 

 

Home
Islamic Dates
ISNA Wrong
Adopting Dates
Saudis Wrong
Diagrams

Slideshow

 

Get all of your town's daily sun & moon information:

 

Home
Introduction
Calendars
Slideshow
Eid al-Adha
Moonsighting FAQ
Hilal Pictures
Articles
Why Confusion
Updates
Volunteers
Links
Archive


Why are Muslim Dates in a Mess?

Muslims around the world started Ramadan 2005 on four solar days/dates (instead of one lunar day/date).

1.   Monday: Nigeria (some Sunday also)
2.   Tuesday: Saudi Arabia, Egypt (Most of Middle East, and followers of Saudi dates)
3.   Wednesday: Australia, Indonesia, Malaysia, Brunei, Turkey, Africa, Europe and Americas
4.   Thursday: Bangladesh, India, Pakistan, Central Asia

This is not the first time it has happened. We at the CFCO have been witnessing this mess for more than thirty years, especially after the communication revolution.

Why are the Islamic dates in such a mess?

Islamic dates are confusing partly because of the crescent moon’s physical observability, but more so because of human errors and deceptive practices.

Nigeria is known for starting Ramadan and fixing Eidain dates a day or two ahead of others.

Saudi Arabia and Egypt agreed in 1999 Jeddah Conference to fix the Islamic dates by “Moonset with or after the sunset.” Earlier, Saudi dates were fixed from the conjunction (the New Moon). The experts there ignored the fact that in some months their fixed date will be BEFORE the conjunction?

Most Middle Eastern states follow Saudi/Egyptian dates, though Oman sometimes waits for the Hilal to be visible.

Bangladesh, India, and Pakistan still follow the Hilal generally, though false witnesses some times create confusion.

Muslim communities in Europe and North America face the worst consequences. Every year they are divided, and their younger generation curses the elders for the mess. Those who follow the Saudi / Egyptian dates are unwilling to accept that the Saudi dates cannot be based on a ‘sighted’ moon there though they cannot see the same moon in N. America 8-11 hours later.

The Islamic dates can easily be calculated if Muslims adopt a few conventions:

1.       The date should be based on a crescent moon’s visibility somewhere in the world;

2.       The date should begin at sunset from a fixed international dateline every month.

If the International Solar Dateline (180E) is adopted also as the lunar dateline then Muslim experts can easily calculate the first dates of each Islamic month when a crescent will be generally visible at 180E.

Of course, every nook and corner of the world will not see the crescent because its visibility is in a parabola. But from New Zealand to Hawaii most will see the Hilal on the same date at their sunset.

CFCO Intl. had calculated and circulated these dates for decades since 1986, but has yet to get public endorsement. It is also a co-signer on an appeal to King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia to seriously consider the proposal, and remove the bottleneck.